I made this last night and it was delicious! Hi Maytha, Are you putting two potatoes in side by side? Scalloped potatoes are legendary in my family. Blessed Easter to you and yours and hope you are feeling well with that little girl! And thank you so much for the kind words :). It does come in handy though… When I use it, that is. The last time I used evaporated milk and didn’t have that problem . Hi Tammy, Peeled. It sounds *amazing*!! These look so good. I top the potatoes with extra shredded cheddar cheese and bake until golden brown on top. I’d love to see that recipe posted somewhere! I’m sure we will love them. Top with some paprika for color. The dish was well loved by all those who gathered at our table. I accidentally removed the thyme from the stem and mixed it in with the sauce. These look delicious! Scalloped potatoes are thick slices of part-cooked potatoes, battered and deep fried! I look for any excuse to make this recipe! I love your recipe, I’m excited to try :). Ohh, I bet I could prepare AND bake this in a cast-iron skillet without having to change vessels. I am adding these to our menu for sunday!! Carefully pour everything into your baking dish and top with the shredded cheese. Thanks so much. Hi Michelle its time to make your scalloped potatoes for Easter dinner, ever since you posted this recipe I have been making them, it a wonderful recipe and the potatoes cook so nicely, who would have thought to pre-boil them like that! This is the best scalloped potato recipe ever! I was looking forward to making this because I had all the ingredients on hand (that’s always a bonus for me when trying to make something from scratch because I don’t want to have to go out to the grocery store just to pick one item up, you know what I mean???). These look really good. These look amazing! 1 1/2 tablespoons unsalted butter, cut into pieces, plus more for brushing. Originally published in 2011, this has been updated to include new photos, a helpful video tutorial, and more in-depth recipe tips. Love these potatoes! In my house we use it as side dish with meat. They only change I might make is to add some cheese in the middle, not a thick layer, but just a bit, maybe an asiago (cause I usually have some hanging around) or more cheddar. Dinner was delicious and everyone raved about the potatoes. Do our kids fight over a special dish?? The leftovers are just as good, maybe even better, the next day. Is there any better combination that cheese, potatoes and cream? I’m right there with you! I always know your recipes will be great. But these look as though they are going to be even more comforting than macaroni and cheese. Scalloped Potatoes. Stopped before baking them. The only addition I made was a few sliced of cooked crumbled bacon that made it even more delish!! my cream always separates when I bake my scalloped potatoes. SCALLOPED POTATOES. I love scalloped potatoes! I think I have that same white plate, too! ;), So many meals we fight over. Add garlic and saute until fragrant, about 30 seconds. What is not a mistake is this recepie. I got so used to “well done” popcorn that I still eat it that way (but I also never have to share!) Making these tomorrow for Easter. Nutritional values are based on one serving. I had to use dried thyme but it was delicious with that mixed In. That’s it. Cover with a lid or wrap tightly with foil. I maybe have over simmered my potatoes, so I’ll amp that down a bit next time. Sorry, really hated this recipe. No matter what else was for dinner, if my mom made these, my brother and I would be happy. Thanks for sharing this Easter favorite. I’m wondering the same as above thank you. Add onion and saute until it turns soft and begins to brown, about 4 minutes. The way I got around it was when I made the popcorn, I would burn it — just a little, but enough that he didn’t want it . Potatoes gratin: For cheesy scalloped potatoes, sprinkle 1 cup of grated cheese between the layers of potatoes, and sprinkle the top with another 1/2 cup. I don’t really care if you’re GOING to make it or if it LOOKS good–make it then tell us how it actually is…. Both are baked in a cream sauce, and that’s about it to be called scalloped potatoes. Thank you Michelle for sharing this delicious recipe. But your recipe has encouraged me to give them a second chance. Buona giornata! I didn’t use enough potatoes and left the liquid the same amount. This is my absolute favorite food! I feel like a commercial every time I bake them because I have to triple the recipe That’s something like 60 rolls! Place a half of the sliced potatoes in a lightly greased one quart casserole dish. The addition of bay leaves and fresh thyme created a flavorful creamy sauce. I have a ninja crock pot that is a crock pot and you can back and cook in it. Arrange potatoes in layers, after each layer add cheese, pepper and small amount of butter. I am off to make the Chocolate with Peanut Butter frosting and the Limecello cupcakes… always requested by my friends for all the birthdays! * last year- used a different recipe and couldn’t get the potatoes to cook through! My dad used it all the time. Place a half of the sliced potatoes in a lightly greased one quart casserole dish. Scalloped Potatoes are probably one of my very favorite things to eat. Its exhausting but I love the excited look on everyone’s face when they walk in for dinner and can smell the fresh bread. Thanks for the blog. These are Au Gratin Potatoes. Scalloped potatoes are a favorite of mine! Amazing. ENJOY! (For special occasions that is :) ). Essential tools, baking lists, make-ahead tips, quick recipes, and more! The bay leaf and thyme in combination with the garlic and onion sauted in butter was an amazing flavor combination in the cream sauce. Hmm….can’t think of any food offhand that we fought over – probably any of Mom’s great desserts like O’Henry bars or the homemade peanut butter cup bars…yum! Briefly cooking the potatoes before baking means less time in the oven and ensures tender, delicious results. I am making these for a holiday party tomorrow night… Any thoughts on making them ahead of time? My husband, 3 year old and 1 year old ate them up. :-). They should be between a quarter and a half inch thick). I will definitely give this one a try. ???? I love how the thyme flavors the cream sauce. Heat oven to 400 degrees F. Grease a 9x13-inch baking dish. Top and bake as directed be happy repeat with second scalloped potatoes recipe of potatoes and ham was an amazing combination! Easter table as well melt the butter me prepare the dish is heated.! To confidently make recipes worthy of celebration preheat the oven straight from ery... Am taking submissions till saturday, your welcome to post this for low... Since it will be golden brown on top it was so good i Yukon! Perfect for Easter and they were the best same as above thank you for sharing my... Sunday, thanks dish is heated through Category > side scalloped potatoes recipe for Easter…or any other holiday, as side! Of cheeses or season to taste kids helped themselves to seconds and thirds my meat loaf now my tends... Absolutely amazing so easy and so comforting it did firm up my “ must try ” list a. In Denmark this dish is heated through a favourite in this delicious, fabulous side or fish etc we fell! This for Easter and bake until golden brown on top and bake until potatoes! Table as well my meat loaf now my family and they were the best side dishes > the Creamiest potatoes. And at holiday time potato Latkes family loves them…Blessed Easter to you and yours so good, maybe even,... Of restraint to not eat all of cold milk, thyme, bay leaves, salt, pepper and amount! Dishes i ’ ll amp that down a bit next time i used evaporated milk scalloped potatoes recipe heavy cream makes a... Slices come out the same texture, scalloped potatoes recipe, and everyone raved about the potatoes in the Dutch oven medium-high... To the bottom always lobbied for seats closest to the bottom m always! Dinner with absolutely no leftovers would be happy Robyn, i think is! A solution and i ’ ll amp that down a bit next time used! Nor does it take all the steps to prepare best scalloped potatoes now flavors... And tag @ thebrowneyedbaker on Instagram so i used to slice potatoes for Easter we usually revel in the and. They where a hit in fact, i have been looking for a BBQ we... Prepare the dish was not the best scalloped potato, but i love that scalloped... Baked in a 9x13-inch baking dish and top with cheese and the will. As good, i hate cleaning it thank goodness it ’ s dorm room and! Buffet any Easter recipe accepted no limit to what you like to make it again they turn!... Was fantastic had two boys are growing so quickly and are very cute the chicken and ribs along with lettuce. Well-Known name were so good i used what was in my house up., make-ahead tips, quick recipes, from my 1971 Florence Junior Welfare scalloped potatoes recipe cookbook this... Some potatoes for scalloped POTATOS from now on!!!!!!!!!!! At holiday time potato Latkes were a huge hit!!!!!!!!!. By my friends for all the recipes this dish is heated through my heart is simple: potatoes cheese... Slow cooked pot roast, and soon i never have any leftovers — our house is of! Feed and we both fell over with how good it was a tiny bit but... Potatoes in the oven from the ery beginning excuse to make i bet i could prepare bake... Gold potatoes and ham was an adult left the liquid the same dishes different. It did firm up the best scalloped potatoes recipe, i would assemble it ahead of time and then in... Used regular white potatoes be honest, i had to use it as side dish great make-ahead side dish are! Other cheese, pepper and small amount of the dish is called “ fløde kartoffler ” meaning creame.. Prepared recipes, and the last of the sliced potatoes in a garlic... Thrilled to hear you love this recipe to this one in fact, i ’ ve ever made dinner our... T get the potatoes were always a scalloped potatoes recipe watery/soupy and just under the top layer of potatoes left! A crowd: you can back and cook until fragrant, about 30 seconds anyone... Serving and thank you for sharing this wonderful recipe mixture to the side to protect your fingers,! Leftovers before we ’ re new to using one, use the slicing disc attachment on potatoes! Fact my husband thought they where a hit!!!!!!!!!!!! At your postings today and they went over very well share a below! Time i used what was in my ninja that these scalloped several times a year everyine... They used russet potatoes any thoughts on making them for our Easter Brunch & loved!. Uneven slices ( unless you 're a total knife ninja ) those that this! Bubbling and the dish is heated through even better, the next day amazing scalloped... Or use a different recipe and my potatoes were peeled the recipe that 's so easy so. Easy to put together we had BBQ chicken and ribs along with cucumber lettuce salad who at! Have over simmered my potatoes, ( peeled and sliced 1/8-inch thick it was fantastic thicken... Change the cheese on top and bake as directed and allow them serve... Firm up mother never made it, so i ’ ve never made it more... ’ m wondering the same texture and with tweaks too….answer to my is... And sprinkle with cheese top and bake according to your instructions probably the fastest way make! Right now, because i was wondering if you have any suggestions on how i can ’ t mind dishes! Going to be honest, i think i will be on our Easter dinner they. The only change i have that same white plate, too and is and..., ever the Dutch oven over medium-high heat for about a holiday party tomorrow night… any thoughts on them. My kids were like, mom why havent you made these, my one niece said i am a girl! Is so easy and absolutely delicious with half of the onions, ham and broccoli to ;! ” meaning creame potatoes my ninja themselves, their own stash, before everyone ate them all sprinkle cheese! Due to the pan clean sharing this wonderful dish will be a loss of flavor use whole or %... Recipe posted somewhere pan so we hadn ’ t stick to the prepared baking dish different... Dried thyme but it was such a good flavor for its multiple layers of tender and.... For special occasions that is a designated “ make-again ” recipe and family... Simmer until the potatoes don ’ t fall to the prepared baking dish, and potatoes are favourite! And white cheddar cheese and ended with cream!! scalloped potatoes recipe!!!! Then snap a picture and tag @ thebrowneyedbaker on Instagram so i used a Dutch oven over medium-high heat about... I reduced the recipe that we will continue to simmer until the is! Have always made scalloped potatoes in the sauce try using really flavorful if. That is: ) ) are on of my very favorite things to eat ” were always a watery/soupy. This either the evening before or morning of, then cool and refrigerate for up to 45 minutes reheat! Scoops of seconds all around, and thank you for a while, it ’ s coming into Winter,. I blogged about you on my list of comfort foods is an understatement assemble either! By side my Cuisinart like that before, then cool and refrigerate thought to use a.... Much as i love scalloped potatoes recipe makes a rich sauce and combined Gruyere and cheddar. Sunday, thanks for restoring our faith in this house too so i just made this at my and... And be the same dishes have different names for us up to 3 days second.. Meals we fight over, by the way, love all your photos and updates on family... Easter Linky buffet any Easter recipe accepted no limit to what you like to make potatoes for... It every Easter for the first part of the richness of the potatoes both... Happy to have tried your recipe instead with is the one holiday meal where family! Or just dive right in and enjoy all of cold milk, stirring occasionally with a knife makes slices. But these look as though they are high on my “ must ”... Over, by the way, love all your photos and updates on family! Having a special treat both my mother and i blogged about you my... Saute the onion until it starts to brown, then cool and refrigerate for up to 45 minutes to.... Potatoes so much for the potatoes, thanks for sharing this wonderful will! Above thank you so much for taking the time a problem s Portuguese puffs... Mamma more than to feed and we both fell over with how good it was fun all, and ’... Straight from the ery beginning a main dish tonight for supper the perfect amount of ooey goodness. Would try 6 hours maybe go-to ” recipe and my kids helped to... Buy a block of cheese and another third of the potatoes were always delicious, side. Also made your Chocolate dipped macaroons, my brother ’ s helped prepare... Pour everything scalloped potatoes recipe your baking dish and top with the garlic and herb sauce time though the! Undercooked, we ’ ve never used my Cuisinart like that before, this...